Liquidator charged with intention to defraud

 Charges laid, Prosecution of Liquidators, White collar crime  Comments Off on Liquidator charged with intention to defraud
Aug 272010
Mr Stuart Ariff – the former liquidator whose actions gave rise to the Inquiry into Liquidators and Administrators currently being conducted by the Australian Senate – was arrested on 23 August 2010 and is now facing 19 criminal charges. He has been released on bail.
In a media release the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) said that the alleged offences relate to Mr Ariff’s conduct when liquidator of HR Cook Investments Pty Ltd.
Mr Ariff has been charged with 13 counts of intention to defraud. They relate to his alleged transfer of funds totalling $1.18 million. These charges are under section 176A of the NSW Crimes Act, and each count carries a maximum penalty of 10 years imprisonment.
 In R v Giam (No 2) (1999) A Crim R 348 Dunford J said of an offence under section 176A : “Courts have drawn attention in the past to the seriousness of white collar crime, and offences under s 176A in particular, as it involves not only fraud but also breach of the trust involved in being a director of a company. Such offences call for significant sentences, particularly where the amount fraudulently obtained is large: R v Glenister [1980] 2 NSWLR 597, R v Pantano [1990] 49 A Crim R 328.”


Mr Ariff has also been charged with six counts under section 1308(2) of the Corporations Act 2001 alleging he made false statements in accounts of receipts and payments lodged with ASIC relating to this particular liquidation. Each count carries a maximum fine of $22,000 or imprisonment for five years or both.

The case against Mr Ariff is being prosecuted by the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions.


To comment click Read More

Insolvency Inquiry: Treasury’s Guide

 Australian Senate 2009-2010, Official Inquiries  Comments Off on Insolvency Inquiry: Treasury’s Guide
Aug 182010

In December 2009 the Australian Senate Economics Committee invited the Treasury Department to make a submission to its inquiry into liquidators and administrators. Treasury obliged in February 2010 by pointing the Senate Committee to some useful background material. A copy of  Treasury’s covering letter is produced below.  I have added a few comments to improve and update the internet links.  [The Committee subsequently questioned Treasury and requested more information. Copies of these exchanges will be included in a future post to this site.]

An overview of the relevant legal framework is attached for the assistance of the Committee.  There are a number of completed reviews and reports that deal with many of the issues encompassed by the Committee’s terms of reference. The Committee may find it useful to review these in the course of the Inquiry.

Corporate Insolvency Laws: A Stocktake

The Parliamentary Joint Committee on Corporations and Financial Services (PJC) released the Corporate Insolvency Laws: A Stocktake report in 2004. The PJC recommended that the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) work with professional bodies to encourage the adoption of best practice standards for remuneration and the prompt disclosure of the basis of fees charged by liquidators and administrators. A copy of this report is available at: 

Review of the Regulation of Corporate Insolvency Practitioners

A review of the regulation of corporate insolvency practitioners was completed in 1997 (Report of the Working Party on the Review of the Regulation of Corporate Insolvency Practitioners, June 1997). The recommendations contained in the Report of the Working Party cover eight areas: 

  • regulatory system;
  • registering authority for insolvency practitioners;
  • registration requirements; discipline and remedial supervision;
  • general supervision; appointments and qualifications;
  • remuneration of insolvency practitioners; and
  • administrative requirements for controllers.

A copy of the Report is available on the Treasury website at:   

The following materials have also been issued by ASIC or by the insolvency Practitioners Association.

•             Guide to Fees of insolvency practitioners

•             Approving Fees: a Guide for Creditors

Copies of these documents can be downloaded from    NOTE BY pjk:  A more useful link is the following:$file/Approving_fees_guide_for_creditors.pdf 

Insolvency Practitioners Association  

The IPA Code of Professional Practice (The Code) addresses a range of matters dealing with the conduct of insolvency practitioners. This includes setting out a series of principles that should be followed in regard to practitioner. Included in the Code is a Creditor Information Sheet for approving remuneration in external administrations. A copy of the Code can be downloaded from  

Listed below are a number of remuneration and conduct related reforms passed or initiated in recent years. 

Corporations Amendment (insolvency) Act 2007

These amendments were the first significant change to Australia’s insolvency laws since 1993 and focused on improving outcomes for creditors, deterring misconduct by company officers, improving regulation of insolvency practitioners and voluntary administration. These reforms introduced the requirement for liquidators and administrators to complete Declarations of Relevant Relationships. Administrators are also required to complete Declarations of Indemnities. In relation to remuneration, there was a codification of principles and improvements in the information available to creditors and the Court. This included the Insertion of criteria into the Corporations Act for the Court to consider when assessing the reasonableness of an external administrator’s claim for remuneration.  

Personal Insolvency Reform

The Bankruptcy Legislation Amendment Bill 2009 was introduced in the House of Representatives on 28 October 2009. The Bill aims to provide a more streamlined process for fixing trustee remuneration and a more transparent process for reviewing remuneration. The Attorney‑General’s Department has released a discussion paper, Amendments to the Bankruptcy Regulations 1996: Remuneration of Registered Trustees, which is available at

 International resources and guidelines 

The Office of Fair Trading (OFT) in the United Kingdom has recently launched a study into Corporate Insolvency. The study will look at the market structure, regulation, remuneration and competition between firms and practitioners. Initially, this will involve collection and analysis of data from interested parties including accountancy and law firms, government, regulators and industry. Further investigations will depend on the results of the initial investigation. The OFT expect to complete their investigation by the end of 2010. Information regarding this study can be found at:

 Final report of OFT

 In April 2001 the World Bank released a detailed statement of principles and guidelines for effective insolvency and creditor rights systems:   


To leave a comment, click READ MORE